The High Cost of Summertime Electricity

Posted on January 5th, 2018

Intuitively, it seems the demand for electricity should be highest during winter’s cold, dark days. However, it’s the summertime demand for air conditioning and the huge amount of electricity it consumes that drives up utilities’ cost of supplying electricity. Understanding what makes the costs go up can help commercial and industrial facilities reduce monthly electric bills.

The Prime Cost Driver

Electric utilities are required to meet the prime directive:

“Supply all the electricity customers want…whenever they want it.”

This simple, but unconstrained, requirement is the principal driver of costs in the supply of electricity. It compels utilities to meet huge demands for electricity 24/7/365 without warning, without exception and without cost limitations. The cost of excess generating and delivery capability to do this is very high.

Figure 1 shows annual winter (blue) and summer (yellow) peak electricity demand and for the 48 contiguous states from 1990 to 2016. The red columns are the extra installed generating capacity, called the reserve margin, needed to meet all prime directive contingencies such as unexpected power plant outages during peak summertime demand. The dark line shows how the national average price of electricity, unsurprisingly, tracks the installed capacity.

To get a feel for the magnitude of the cost of supplying electricity, consider the smallest reserve margin shown in Figure 1, 103,800 MW in 1999. At 2018 building costs, that amount of installed generating capacity would cost $72 billion, not including transmission lines or other infrastructure.

A graph showing Winter vs. Summer Peak Electricity Demand

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

High, Higher, Highest.

Adjusting electricity generation up and down to match daily demand variations is especially challenging in the summertime, June through September, because the peaks can be very high but also very short in duration. Table 1 shows how high and short the peak demand can be.

The annual demand for electricity in 2016 New York State arranged by demand duration is shown in Table 1. Satisfying the highest summer peak requires 28% (7,000 MW) of the generating capacity operate for 112 hours or just 1.3% of a year. That 7,000 MW equates to 90 to 120 generating plants. These plants sit idle not generating revenue most of the year but add substantially to the cost of electricity.

A table showing the 2016 Demand Duration for New York State

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Conquering the Peak

A daily summer electricity demand profile is shown in Figure 2. Serving the high, short duration peak load requires a special type of generating plant: a peaking plant a.k.a. “peaker”. These are the plants described above as sitting idle most of the year. Simple cycle gas turbines are commonly used as peakers because they:

  • Achieve full load from a cold start in minutes,
  • Can start when the electric grid is down (black start),
  • Install quickly and in a small footprint, and
  • Come in small sizes (<75 MW)

On the downside, peakers have relatively high maintenance costs and high greenhouse gas emissions as well as a cost of generating electricity up to 5 times that of a base-load plant. So, the need to operate peakers adds significantly to the cost of supplying electricity.

Base-load units include nuclear and large, efficient fossil plants and are the money-makers producing electricity at the lowest $/MW-hr cost. Often taking a day or longer to start up, base-load units are most efficient at full load and are run there as long as possible once started. Intermediate or “load-following” units usually produce fewer MWs than their base-load counterparts, but they start much faster and have good efficiency across a wide range of load points. This operational flexibility makes their $/MW-hr cost slightly higher than based-load units but much better than peakers.

A graph showing the Daily Summer Electricity Demand

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Delivery Cost

Like the generation reserve margin described above, transmission and distribution systems must have sufficient extra current-carrying capacity to meet huge summer peaks. However, adding transmission lines is usually very challenging especially near urban areas where new rights-of-way are virtually nonexistent. In that case, transmission line upgrades may be a solution. A $120 million transmission line upgrade in 2016 allowed an additional 440 MW of power flow to the New York City area from upstate.

Whether new lines or upgrades, expanding transmission & distribution capacity adds to the cost of electricity.

Baby…It’s Hot Out There

Besides increasing demand, high summer temperatures and humidity adversely affect the performance of mechanical and electrical equipment, such as:

  • Higher cooling water temperatures and humidity can reduce the efficiency of coolers, condensers, chillers, etc.,
  • High air temperatures increase fuel consumption and reduce output for gas turbine peakers and other types of generators,
  • Higher temperatures increase electrical resistance which reduces the efficiency of transmission and distribution lines, electric motors, transformers and more,
  • Fan efficiency goes down as air temperature increases and air density decreases, and

These reduced efficiencies and capacities line up in the same direction to drive up the cost of supplying electricity.

Shave & Shift

Clearly, extremely hot and humid summertime days send the demand for air conditioning soaring at a time when generating and delivering electricity to power air conditioning is least efficient. This increases the year-round cost of supplying electricity through:

  • Increasing reserve margins,
  • Having numerous idle, non-revenue producing generating plants,
  • Operating inefficient peak-load plants,
  • Requiring extra capacity needed for transmission & distribution, and
  • Decreasing equipment efficiency caused by high temperatures and humidity.

For commercial and industrial customers, there is good news in this. Electric utilities and Federal, state and local agencies have heavily discounted electricity rates and other financial incentives to reward customers willing to help shave (reduce) demand peaks and shift loads (to off-peak times). With new technological advances and significant incentives, it’s a great time to check out all the opportunities to save money on electric bills.

See how much you can save money on electric bills using new technologies for peak shaving and load shifting (Figure 3) by contacting your ENGIE MEP representative.

Graph depicting Daily Electricity Demand of Peak Shaving & Load Shifting

 

 

Our multiple locations also allow us to serve all of the Mid-Atlantic and Northeast U.S.